This is the place to discuss new and old movies or DVD releases of movies. You can also create topics about your favorite actor/actress.
Please post topics related to new productions of the MSCL cast and crew into the "Afterlife" forum.
Post Reply
User avatar
MSCL.com Team
MSCL.com Team
Posts: 1561
Joined: Jun 10th 1999, 5:20 pm
Location: Switzerland


Post by Sascha » Sep 4th 2005, 4:11 am

Found this raving review of a TV movie on Showtime/Lifetime -- which is apparently airing tomorrow (Monday 5 September). It caught my eye because it compares the movie to "one of television's best series, My So-Called Life":

Jonathan Storm | 'Speak' star says a lot with little dialogue

By Jonathan Storm

Inquirer Columnist

Made for 1 percent of the cost of HBO's $100 million Rome epic, a little movie to be televised simultaneously on Showtime and Lifetime at 9 tomorrow night demonstrates that art trumps money every time.

It is Speak, adapted from Laurie Halse Anderson's novel about a high school freshman who [spoiler] turns nearly mute after she's raped at an end-of-summer party[/spoiler]. Despite spare dialogue, it shimmers with emotion and finds moments of humor as well. And it features a young woman who could be a big-time movie star, if she wants the job.

This is a story with a history. It was a National Book Award finalist, and six years after publication, was ranked No. 11 on the Aug. 15 Publishers Weekly list of best-selling children's fiction, the most recent one available. The book is widely taught in high schools.

Speak is director Jessica Sharzer's first feature. Hired late in the process by executives who were impressed by a student movie she made, Sharzer, 32, said in a phone interview that she shot the movie in three weeks in 2003.

She took advantage of summer vacation at the Columbus, Ohio, school where much of the action occurs, and of the hiatus of producer Fred Berner (who has helped make such features as Miss Firecracker and Pollock) from Law & Order: Criminal Intent.

Her first job was to rework the script.

"The best bet was to stay as close to the novel as I possibly could," she said. "The kids who have read that book five and 10 times because they loved it so much should be relieved to see the book that they remember on the screen."

The movie is reminiscent of one of television's best series, My So-Called Life, which ignited Claire Danes' career. Kristen Stewart stars as Melinda Sordino. She was 13 when the film was made two years ago, just off feature turns as the daughter of Jodie Foster in Panic Room and of Sharon Stone and Dennis Quaid in Cold Creek Manor.

Her performance in Speak is breathtaking.

"Something about Kristen really allows for women to project onto her," Sharzer said, "but also men can connect with that character with no problem. I did not want the movie to be a 'chick flick.' That's a false category used to suppress some films. There are seriously likable characters who are men in the movie."

Speak has broad appeal beyond the high school audience. Though too mature for young elementary-schoolers, it makes a superior family viewing experience

D.B. Sweeney plays Melinda's father, Elizabeth Perkins her mother. Both characters are clueless.

"I don't want to know," the mother says to begin the movie, as she comes upon Melinda painting her face with lipstick bars that look like stitches to fasten her mouth. "A chicken pot pie is defrosting on the counter. Dad is not home, and I'm going to therapy."

The dark humor is never gut-busting, always tinged with at least a trace of Melinda's pain.

"You're the most depressed person I ever met," the perky new kid at school says, "and excuse me for saying this, but I think you need professional help."

Through it all, Stewart, with the sparest of dialogue, conveys a broken girl's emotions, primarily confusion. But she is no lifeless rag doll.

"Her face is so open," Sharzer said, "that when you're watching her react to things, you're filling out the inner monologue. Voiceover makes it much funnier, but you lose the impact of the fact that she's not speaking."

And so the voiceover is lightly used, not as pervasive as it was in My So-Called Life. Sharzer was in college and missed that show when it aired on ABC in 1994-95, but a friend gave her a couple of episodes to watch. "And I've met Winnie Holzman," she beamed.

Holzman created My So-Called Life, which, in its first episode, finds Danes thinking these classic lines: "School is a battlefield, for your heart" and "The cafeteria is the embarrassment capital of the world. It's like a prison movie."

In Speak, Melinda thinks, "Gym should be illegal."

"All of the voiceover comes directly out of the novel," Sharzer said.

Showtime will televise the 90-minute movie intact. Sharzer had to cut it to accommodate all the commercials in Lifetime's two-hour window.

Her student movie, "The Wormhole," which won prizes at New York University, starred a 10-year-old character addressing the loss of his brother.

"I love working with children," Sharzer said, "because they're not trained and because they're not as guarded as adults are. Their responses to things are much more natural and authentic."

It's obvious why the director had such raves for Stewart, daughter of a TV stage manager who has worked on such shows as The Jamie Kennedy Experiment and The Weakest Link. "She can do anything she wants," Sharzer said. "But I don't know if she wants to be a star. She's a pretty private person."

The future looks good for the young director, as well.

Fox passed on a pilot she wrote ("a revenge drama about a wealthy family"), and now Sharzer is writing the big-screen Dusty Springfield Story, to star Kristin Chenoweth, for Universal Studios. The budget will be a bit bigger than for Speak.

"A tight budget and a tight schedule are great directing exercises," she said. "They force you to make decisions, and the movie always benefits when you have to decide what's important and what can go.

"A lot of big-budget movies are flaccid because nobody ever has to make those decisions."

Tell that to HBO.

Jonathan Storm |

TV Review


Tomorrow at 9 p.m. on Lifetime and Showtime
http://www.philly.com/mld/philly/entert ... 533544.htm
Last edited by Sascha on Sep 17th 2005, 4:54 pm, edited 2 times in total.

User avatar
MSCL.com Team
MSCL.com Team
Posts: 1561
Joined: Jun 10th 1999, 5:20 pm
Location: Switzerland

Post by Sascha » Sep 17th 2005, 4:53 pm

I've managed to get ahold of a copy of "Speak" and ... wow! I mean ... WOW! It's truly an amazing movie. If there were such a thing as an "Annual Spirit of 'My-So-Called Life' Award", this movie deserved it big time. I totally agree with everything Jonathan Storm wrote in his review above. Kristen Stewart, just 13 years old when the movie was shot, is a revelation. She could truly be the "next Claire Danes". Her performance is breathtaking.

There are lots of similarities between "Speak" and MSCL, even down to some lines of dialogue, but it's far more than just a copy of MSCL. It tells its own serious and touching, beautiful story, yet it manages to add a spark of humor. Some of the teacher characters seem a bit over-the-top and unrealistic, but maybe that's how the main character sees them.

I highly recommend this movie to everyone who liked "My So-Called Life" (and I guess that's everyone here ;-)). It's available on DVD on September 27, 2005.

User avatar
So-Called Addict
Posts: 989
Joined: Sep 24th 2002, 4:40 am

Post by SanDeE* » Sep 17th 2005, 6:24 pm

The book was really incredible - I read it last week. Not exactly how my first year of high school was, but I certainly know how it feels to lose all your friends (or at least, who you thought were your friends) in a short span of time. That is what I identified most with. I'll have to check out the movie in a couple of weeks.
Um, in my room, one seam is a little off and I stare at it constantly. It's, like, destroying me.


Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests